Why South Dakota v. Wayfair Could Hit Mom-and-Pop Stores
*By Michael Teich*
A landmark e-commerce case being decided by the Supreme Court could have a big impact on mom-and-pop retailers trying to compete with the likes of Amazon, Overstock, and Wayfair.
The nation's highest court is expected to rule in the coming days on whether states can collect sales taxes on residents' online purchases. And a decision in favor of states could put smaller shops at a disadvantage if they too are forced to pay up, said Melissa Armo, owner of The Stock Swoosh.
“It's hard for any small business to compete with these stores,” she said in an interview with Cheddar.
Currently, the law states that retailers are not required to collect sales taxes from consumers unless they have a brick-and-mortar store in the state where that shopper resides. Those rules stem from a 1992 case applying to mail-order retailers. In the current case, *South Dakota v. Wayfair*, the state, along with several others, argues those rules are outdated.
But critics say changing the rules would have broader ramifications, with retailers being forced to comply with thousands of state and local tax authorities at what could be a significant cost.
And Armo questions who ultimately will reap the rewards.
“It’s to benefit the state," she said. "It’s not to benefit the consumer.”
For the full interview, [click here](https://cheddar.com/videos/how-internet-taxes-impact-online-retailers-and-consumers).
AI, BNPL and new digital tools are reshaping holiday shopping. PayPal’s Michelle Gill shares survey insights, tech trends, and tips for smarter spending in 2025
'The Chair Company' blends sharp satire with workplace conspiracy. Lake Bell joins us to talk its corporate themes, quirky characters, and why viewers love it!
Nvidia smashes earnings with record-breaking revenue and soaring Blackwell demand as shares slip this morning, Barron’s senior writer Adam Levine unpacks it all
Jeff Wagoner, CEO of Outrigger Hospitality Group, discusses the company’s coral preservation initiatives and sustainable practices at their hotels and resorts.
Dena Jalbert, Head of M&A at Align Advisory, discusses the state of mergers and acquisitions in 2025 and beyond, highlighting key trends and opportunities.
Kim Perell, author and entrepreneur, shares actionable tips and tricks to help current and aspiring entrepreneurs kick off 2026 with confidence and momentum.
Emera CEO Scott Balfour discusses soaring energy demand, AI-driven grid challenges, clean-power investments, and how the company is building a resilient future.